Fifth Circuit rules undocumented immigrants have no constitutional right to bond hearings
The full 17-judge Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals ruled 10-7 that three detained undocumented immigrants are not entitled to bond hearings on due process grounds. The majority, written by Judge Cory Wilson, held that because the petitioners were still seeking admission, Congress controls detention rules. The ruling curtails a legal avenue used by district judges in Texas, Louisiana and Mississippi to release detainees, and comes as the Supreme Court prepares to hear a related statutory case.
40
Divergence score
This event sits in the top 5% of divergence this week. 6 outlets covered it, splitting into 6 framing camps across 3 bias groups.
6 camps
3 bias groups
The spectrum · how 6 outlets placed this story
LeftCenterRight
New York Times
Washington Examiner
Breitbart
Politico
Reuters
Washington Times
Supportive of action
Neutral
Dismissive
Critical
Alarmist
International angle
Widest split · the two outlets furthest apart, and who published first
Furthest apart on this story
New York Times
Appeals Court Backs Trump on Constitutionality of Detentions
Rights-curtailing, dissent-heavy · negative
Washington Examiner
Appeals court sides with Trump on indefinite illegal immigrant detention policy
Administration victory · positive
First to report
- Reutersfirst
- Politico+18 min
- New York Times+7.5 h
- Washington Examiner+8.0 h
- Washington Times+10.6 h
- Breitbart+13.0 h
By each outlet's earliest publish time in this story. Feeds that index slowly can appear later than they printed.
The split, in one line
The right frames the ruling as a big win for Trump's immigration agenda and no get-out-of-jail card; the left stresses it shores up ICE mass detention against nine of 11 circuits that rejected the policy.
How each outlet covered it
Two readings of the same facts
The left and the right lead with different language. The loaded words each chose are highlighted.
40DIVERGENCE
THE RIGHT
“Appeals court says Trump's immigration detention policies are constitutional”WT Washington Times RIGHT
DOWN THE MIDDLE
“Appeals court shores up ICE mass detention policy” · Politico, Reuters
+Hide the full sourcingSee how all 6 outlets put it
CENTER2
PPolitico Appeals court shores up ICE mass detention policy 1d ago RReuters Detained migrants have no constitutional right to bond hearings, US court rules 1d ago RIGHT3
WEWashington Examiner Appeals court sides with Trump on indefinite illegal immigrant detention policy 1d ago BBreitbart Federal Court Says No 'Get Out of Jail' Card for Illegal Aliens 1d ago WTWashington Times Appeals court says Trump's immigration detention policies are constitutional 1d ago 6 tracked claims across 6 outlets
Fact ledger
All6Corroborated6
5/6
Corroborated
The full Fifth Circuit ruled 10-7 that the three detainees have no constitutional right to bond hearings
Corroborated
Disputed
5 more tracked claimsSign up free to see the full ledger